Friday, January 20, 2012

Theocratic Libertarianism


You probably know about Gary North already, but if you don't, you should. He represents an offshoot of the Austrian school that is a blend of Austrian economics and Dominionism.
Gary North, son-in-law of the late Rousas Rushdoony, is one of the most prolific Christian Reconstructionist writers.  He is also an adjunct scholarwith the Ludwig von Mises Institute (the U.S. center for Austrian economics), recipient of the its 2004 Rothbard Medal, and contributor of hundreds of articles for LewRockwell.com, the newsletter of the institute's founder and chairman. Link to my previous article on this topic, Waiting for the Day When We Can Say We're All Austrians: Ron Paul's Brand of Libertarianism.
North's writing explains the theocratic libertarianism of Christian Reconstructionism, a Dominionist movement which would dramatically reduce the federal government and control society through enforcement of biblical law at the local and state levels. Theocratic libertarianism has become a foundational philosophy for some of the Religious Right, but it is also surprisingly seductive to Tea Partiers and young people, some of whom may not fully understand what is supposed to happen after the federal government is stripped of its regulatory powers.

Following are quotes by Gary North in from the 1980s when he was part of a core group of Christian Reconstructionists in Tyler, Texas building the movement.  North stated in the introduction to his 1989 book Myth of Pluralism,  
"I am trying to lay the biblical foundations of an alternative society to humanism's present social order."
Christian Reconstructionism is often described as the movement that wants to execute adulterers, blasphemers, and homosexuals, by stoning.  Since this is not likely to happen any time soon, the movement is often dismissed as fringe and inconsequential.  The preoccupation with the stoning aspect has obscured the fact that many other foundational components of the movement have been mainstreamed in the Religious Right since the time when Gary North wrote the following words.  As you read the following quotes, consider how much of North's philosophy is now commonplace, not only in the Christian Right but also in this year's political campaigns.
Read the rest at Talk to Action
Theocratic Libertarianism: Quotes from Gary North, Ludwig von Mises Institute Scholar
by Rachel Tabachnick
(h/t Yves Smith)

Curious blend of Rothbard's extreme version of anarcho-capitalism (privatize the oceans) and far-right religious fanaticism. This would be merely a curiosity if it weren't making headway politically and now actually becoming influential in some ways, disguised of course. This post takes the wraps off.
In closing, I would argue that North's advice has been taken very seriously over the last 30 years by much of the Christian Right, and that Christian Reconstructionism has been at least partially successful in redefining the meaning of "freedom" and "liberty" in a way that has escaped the notice of much of the American public.
UPDATE: This just in from Kevin Fathi via email.

The Irrepressible Rothbard
Essays of Murray N. Rothbard
Edited by Llewellyn H. Rockwell, Jr.
RIGHT-WING POPULISM
(Scroll down to read the juicy stuff)

Pretty much the current GOP talking points.

Related:
Who Wrote Ron Paul's Newsletters? Libertarian movement veterans, and a Paul campaign staffer, say it was "paleolibertarian" strategist Lew Rockwell
Ron Paul doesn't seem to know much about his own newsletters. The libertarian-leaning presidential candidate says he was unaware, in the late 1980s and early 1990s, of the bigoted rhetoric about African Americans and gays that was appearing under his name. He told CNN last week that he still has "no idea" who might have written inflammatory comments such as "Order was only restored in L.A. when it came time for the blacks to pick up their welfare checks"—statements he now repudiates. Yet in interviews with reason, a half-dozen longtime libertarian activists—including some still close to Paul—all named the same man as Paul's chief ghostwriter: Ludwig von Mises Institute founder Llewellyn Rockwell, Jr.
Read it at Reason
Who Wrote Ron Paul's Newsletters?
by Julian Sanchez & David Weigel | January 16, 2008

Rockwell was Paul's congressional chief of staff from 1978 to 1982 and vice president of Ron Paul & Associates, which published the Ron Paul Political Report and the Ron Paul Survival Report, until its dissolution in 2001.

Anyone seeing a pattern here?

8 comments:

Matt Franko said...

OMG, Tom, OMG...

Anonymous said...

Wow. I've occasionally read North over at Rockwell's site, but had no idea that he is the son in law of Rousas Rushdoony.

Tom Hickey said...

Rhymes with "loony."

Matt Franko said...

I think Ron Paul gets all of his $$ from the gold companies...

Ryan Harris said...

This is the problem in trying to get behind candidates that support liberty issues. To build a coalition you have to join with the persecuted who are by definition cracked pots, cranks and fanatics.

Matt Franko said...

Tom,

Ive had some time to look into this...

The only commonality I see for one is they are Libertarians of the Right.

These people, whether at Reason Mag., Ron Paul's, Murray Rothbard, Ayn Rand, these far right members of Christendom, etc... They are definitely Libertarians, and they are on the political right.

This is Rothbards wiki page (ive never looked at it before), it reads a lot like Ayn Rand's bio, same religious background (Old Testament), academia, libertarianism, etc...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murray_Rothbard

Then you point out these nominal Christians here involved with this Christian Reconstructionist movement (which Ive never heard of before but looks like it is a big deal in Christendom) and they are very into the OT things like stoning prostitutes and homosexuals (??????!).

So a lot of this may come from a complete obsession with a deranged enforcement of certain of the OT laws looks like, or certain aspects of the OT way of life and the OT economy, which may directly lead to their modern day Libertarianism and "hands off" govt ideas.

Whether these folks come from a traditionally Jewish or traditionally Christendom background, it looks like they seek not to be subject to a civil govt which is the textbook OT approach (under OT laws, the human only subject to God, not each other). They all maybe are being drawn into this confused chaotic approach which is not applicable for us today imo.

It seems like it is a confused politics or philosophy or dogma or whatever that transcends Judeo-Christendom today and has many people caught up in it.

I would recommend a thorough immersion into Paul's letter to the Romans for them as a start and see if it sobers them up.

Very disturbing otherwise...

Resp,

Tom Hickey said...

Matt, it's pretty obvious that they either have not read the NT or they reject Paul. And, yes, once you find out about them, it's really OMG. Then when you investigate it further (check out investibative reporter Jeff Sharlet's work on The Family ) it is OMG squared.

But what I find contradictory is that they reject authority (government) and accept (self-defined) "biblical law," which is manifestly an authoritarian imposition of a set of norms by a socio-political group on society. Looks to me like pathology rather than just confusion.

This is driving US politics on the right, in a disguised form to slip under the radar. It is a serious obstacle to the acceptance of MMT policy solutions anytime soon in this country.

john f said...

@ Matt Franco Gary North is well aware of Romans as he wrote a commentary on it here.
Cooperation and Dominion: An Economic Commentary on Romans

http://www.garynorth.com/public/512.cfm

@Tom Hickey.He also has written about
Ellen Brown's Web of Debt, which also includes a critique of the Trillion Collar Coin. The critique of the coin just seemed to be a running list of genetic fallacy and poisoning the well errors. Nontheless, he is definitely on to defeating MMT in the public square with his LVMI cohorts.Ellen Brown's Web of Debt Is an Anti-Gold Currency, Pro-Fiat Money, Greenback, Keynesian Tract. Here, I Take It Apart, Error by Error.
http://www.garynorth.com/public/department141.cfm